Rent vs Buy Calculator

Compare renting and buying a US home over your planned stay. Estimate monthly costs, mortgage balance, sale proceeds, investment growth and break-even.

Compare renting and buying

Compare a similar home over the time you expect to stay. Estimates use nominal US dollars.

These are example figures, not current US market averages. Selecting another example replaces the inputs.

Comparison period
Buying
Renting

Enter the rent for a comparable home. Insurance and move-in costs are in Advanced assumptions.

Advanced assumptions

Changing a dollar or percentage basis clears that amount so you can enter the new assumption.

Ownership expenses
Renting expenses
Effective annual returns

Active assumptions

Purchase
Home price: 300000 USD; Down payment: 45000 USD; Fixed mortgage interest rate: 5 % per year; Mortgage term: 360 months
Rent and period
Monthly rent: 1800 USD/month; Comparison period: 120 months
Ownership costs
Purchase closing costs: 6000 USD upfront; Selling costs: 5 % of sale value; Property tax: 1 % of opening yearly home value; Homeowners insurance: 1200 USD/year; HOA dues: 0 USD/month; Maintenance: 1 % of opening yearly home value; Mortgage insurance (PMI): 75 USD/month; Final PMI month: 60 months from purchase; Dollar-based ownership expense growth: 2 % per year
Rental costs
Renters insurance: 20 USD/month; Refundable deposit: 1800 USD upfront; Nonrefundable rental fees: 0 USD upfront; Rent growth: 2 % per year
Growth assumptions
Home appreciation: 2 % per year; Investment return: 4 % per year

Comparison available.

Estimated wealth at month 120

Buying leaves $52,970.99 more estimated wealth at this horizon.

Buying after sale
$142,182.96
Renting with deposit returned
$89,211.97
Buying minus renting
$52,970.99

Monthly housing expenses and equity

Monthly outflows include mortgage principal paid. Equity is before selling costs; net sale proceeds deduct selling costs and remaining debt.

Owning: first month cash outflow
$2,043.90
Renting: first month cash outflow
$1,820.00
Owning: month 120 outflow
$2,085.94
Renting: month 120 outflow
$2,171.17
Mortgage balance
$207,421.49
Home equity before sale
$158,276.84
Net sale proceeds
$139,991.92

Inspect a month

Net wealth after selling or moving out

Follow each household from purchase through 10 yr. Dotted vertical guides mark the first buying lead and changes of leader.

0 yr10 yr

Endpoints at month 120

  • Buying · $142,182.96
  • Renting · $89,211.97
Inspected month 120 · terminal wealth in USD
Buying wealth$142,182.96
Renting wealth$89,211.97
Buying minus renting$52,970.99
ComparisonBuying Ahead

Housing cash outflow · month 120

Both bars use the same dollar scale. Striped mortgage principal repays debt and builds equity.

Buying · $2,085.94
Renting · $2,171.17

The longer bar sets the scale for this month.

View exact cost components for month 120
Monthly expense components (USD)
ExpenseHouseholdCash paid
Mortgage principalBuying$502.55
Mortgage interestBuying$866.35
Property taxBuying$298.77
Homeowners insuranceBuying$119.50
HOA duesBuying$0.00
MaintenanceBuying$298.77
PMIBuying$0.00
RentRenting$2,151.17
Renters insuranceRenting$20.00

When the lead changes

Each band represents consecutive months with the same displayed wealth comparison. Inspect an event or choose any month with the month control.

Solid: buying ahead · dotted: tie · striped: renting ahead

Month 120: Buying Ahead

  • At month 0 the exit wealth estimates differ.
  • No later month has equal displayed wealth.
  • First strict buying lead: month 47.
  • Lead reversals: month 47 (Buying Ahead).
  • Buying stays at least level from month 47 through month 120, with a strict lead during that interval.

Year-by-year comparison

Month-end wealth and expenses in USD. Includes the selected final month.
Year / monthBuying wealthRenting wealthBuying minus rentingComparisonLoan balanceHome equityOwner outflow this monthRenter outflow this month
Year 1 · month 12$39,462.25$55,703.71-$16,241.46Renting Ahead$251,237.75$54,762.25$2,043.90$1,820.00
Year 2 · month 24$49,230.99$60,302.32-$11,071.33Renting Ahead$247,283.01$64,836.99$2,055.90$1,856.00
Year 3 · month 36$59,318.32$64,785.78-$5,467.46Renting Ahead$243,125.96$75,236.44$2,068.14$1,892.72
Year 4 · month 48$69,736.96$69,143.52$593.44Buying Ahead$238,756.21$85,973.44$2,080.62$1,930.17
Year 5 · month 60$80,500.13$73,364.33$7,135.80Buying Ahead$234,162.90$97,061.34$2,093.34$1,968.38
Year 6 · month 72$91,621.69$76,520.12$15,101.57Buying Ahead$229,334.60$108,514.13$2,031.34$2,007.35
Year 7 · month 84$103,146.60$79,508.93$23,637.67Buying Ahead$224,259.27$120,346.43$2,044.59$2,047.09
Year 8 · month 96$115,390.97$82,617.28$32,773.69Buying Ahead$218,924.29$132,573.52$2,058.10$2,087.63
Year 9 · month 108$128,390.67$85,849.98$42,540.69Buying Ahead$213,316.34$145,211.43$2,071.88$2,128.99
Year 10 · month 120$142,182.96$89,211.97$52,970.99Buying Ahead$207,421.49$158,276.84$2,085.94$2,171.17

Nominal USD estimates. Tax deductions, investment taxes, refinancing and unexpected repairs are excluded. Actual lender charges and future returns can differ.

Compare renting and buying

Start with two homes that would meet the same needs. Enter the rent for one and the purchase price for the other. Choose the month you might move: that is when this estimate assumes the owner sells.

  1. Enter the home price, down payment, fixed interest rate, mortgage term and comparable monthly rent.
  2. Open Advanced assumptions for taxes, insurance, HOA dues, repairs, move-in fees and investment returns. Replace the illustrative values with your own figures.
  3. Compare monthly expenses with wealth at your move date. Inspect an earlier month on the charts without changing your planned stay.

What you could have when you move

Home equity is the estimated value of your home less the mortgage you still owe. Selling costs reduce what you take away. The buying result adds those net proceeds to any savings the owner invested. The renting result includes investments and the returned security deposit.

Monthly cash expenses

A mortgage payment includes interest and principal. Property tax, homeowners insurance, HOA dues, maintenance and any mortgage insurance also affect the monthly budget. The renter pays rent and renters insurance. Use the EMI Calculator if you only need a loan repayment schedule.

How the calculation works

Both households start with enough cash to cover the larger upfront requirement. The buyer pays the down payment and closing costs. The renter pays nonrefundable fees and sets aside the deposit. Each household invests its remaining cash.

The fixed mortgage charges monthly interest on the opening debt. Principal payments reduce the balance until payoff. Each month the model gives both households the same budget and invests the cheaper household’s savings at month-end. Growth applies to investments already held. For a separate illustration of recurring contributions, see the SIP Calculator.

Rent and applicable expense increases start on billing-year anniversaries. An annual charge is split into monthly cents that add to the entered yearly amount. The home grows or declines at your assumed appreciation rate. At each possible exit, the model deducts selling costs and the remaining loan once.

Understanding break-even

A tie means both displayed wealth figures agree to the cent. The first strict buying lead can come a month later, or the figures can switch order without ever tying. A reversal marks a change of leader. A sustained buying advantage lasts only through your selected horizon.

Assumptions and exclusions

This is an illustrative estimate, not financial advice or an affordability determination. Investment returns are not guaranteed, and appreciation is an assumption rather than a property forecast. There are no automatic individualized tax deductions. The PMI end month is user-entered and the yearly property assessment is simplified. Actual lender, escrow and sale charges may differ. External financial review of the model remains pending.

Practical examples

Five years: selling before the loan is paid off

Input
Illustration: $120,000 home, $20,000 down, $3,000 purchase costs, 5% selling costs. The $100,000 loan is interest-free for 100 months. Rent is $1,000/month. All other expenses, deposits, growth and returns are zero.
Result
At month 60, buying wealth is $74,000 and renting wealth is $23,000. Buying leads by $51,000.

After 60 payments of $1,000 the debt is $40,000. Selling leaves $120,000 less $6,000 selling costs and $40,000 debt. The renter retains the $23,000 initially invested.

Ten years: savings after payoff

Input
Keep the five-year example’s inputs and extend the horizon to month 120.
Result
Buying wealth is $134,000 and renting wealth is $23,000. Buying leads by $111,000.

Sale proceeds are $114,000 after the $6,000 sale cost. With the mortgage paid off at month 100, the owner invests the $1,000 monthly difference for another 20 months.

A tie comes before the first buying lead

Input
Use the same example and inspect months 9 and 10.
Result
At month 9 both households have $23,000. At month 10 buying leads by $1,000.

The initial $9,000 gap comes from purchase and hypothetical sale costs. Each $1,000 principal payment closes the gap. These simplified figures demonstrate the timing convention, not a typical US mortgage rate.

Frequently asked questions

Is renting cheaper than buying?

Compare the monthly outflows first, then compare what each household could leave with after a sale. Lower monthly bills alone do not establish which household has more wealth at your chosen move date.

How do I find the break-even point?

The timeline compares both households at each month-end. Look for the first equality and the first strict buying lead. A lead can begin between two annual table rows, or the comparison period can end without one.

Is mortgage principal a cost?

Principal leaves your bank account, so it appears in the cash bar. It also reduces the debt you would repay at sale. Interest leaves your account without reducing that debt.

What happens to my down payment?

It becomes part of the owner's equity. The renter can invest cash that would have gone toward the purchase, after paying rental fees and setting aside the refundable deposit.

Does the calculator include property tax?

Yes. Enter annual dollars or a percentage of the home's estimated value at the beginning of each billing year. A local assessment, exemption or escrow bill can differ from this simplified estimate.

Does it include private mortgage insurance (PMI)?

Enter the monthly premium and the last month you expect to pay it. Charges stop by mortgage payoff. Check your loan terms; this estimate does not determine your eligibility for cancellation.

How are investment returns considered?

Both households use the same assumed annual effective return. Each month, the cheaper side invests the cash difference after growth on its opening balance. A negative return can reduce either account.

What happens if home prices fall?

Enter a negative appreciation rate to explore a decline. If selling costs and the remaining mortgage exceed the home's sale value, the estimated sale proceeds are negative.

Can buying take the lead and later fall behind?

Yes. For example, rising ownership expenses can shift the monthly savings to the renter. The timeline marks switches between leaders; a sustained advantage is bounded by the horizon you select.

Are tax deductions included?

No individualized mortgage-interest or property-tax deduction is applied. The investment comparison also excludes investment taxes. Use your own tax circumstances separately.

Related tools